| The picture belongs to a cycle of lunettes
with landscapes and a religious theme. This cycle constitutes a
milestone in the reconstruction of the painting of landscapes in
seventeenth-century Rome. The teaching of Annibale was to remain
an indispensable “school text”, which generations of
Italian and foreign painters, from Lorrain to Poussin, from Dughet
to Swanevelt, were to tackle, even if only dialectically, up to
the end of the century.
Annibale, far from “Flemish dryness”, reveals a natural
world imbued with an ancient spirit - the portrayal of the landscape
through the filter of humanism and of the Italian Renaissance, in
which man and the space which surrounds him live in perfect Arcadian
harmony.
Every landscape element is classically balanced and perfectly integrated
with the learned citing of ancient buildings, working together to
create the so-called “ideal landscape”, that is to say
an heroic and courtly conception of nature, seen in profoundly learned
terms. Giovan Pietro Bellori, in his biography of Annibale Carracci
(1672), mentions a series of six paintings “in the shape of
half moons, with towns and figures from sacred stories, by the hand
of Annibale, and disciples, which were in the lunettes of the chapel
of Palazzo Aldobrandini in the Corso”, paintings which had,
however, already been transferred by that date to the Villa Aldobrandini
on the Quirinal and then finished by inheritance in the hands of
the Doria Pamphilj family by way of the bequest of Olimpia Aldobrandini.
The commission dates back to Cardinal Pietro Aldobrandini, nephew
of Clement VIII, who between 1603 and 1604 asked Annibale to paint
six canvases with the “Stories of the Virgin”, designed
for the chapel, no longer in existence, of his palace on the Corso.
The works begun by Annibale were then passed to his pupil, Francesco
Albani, for reasons so far not fully established; as well as the
hypothesis of a difference between Annibale and the cardinal, on
account of the services the painter still performed for the Farnese,
opponents of the Aldobrandini. There is also the theory, perhaps
nearer to the truth, that the artist was already showing signs of
that illness - according to the sources, a sort of psychophysical
debilitation, today thought to be cerebral arteriosclerosis - which
was to lead to his death in 1609, and the abandonment of his work
in 1607.
It is certain that in 1606, the year in which Pietro Aldobrandini
left Rome following differences with the new pope, Paul V Borghese,
before returning in 1610, the cycle had not been completed. Albani
would be paid for it in the years between 1605 and 1613, which demonstrates
that Annibale had abandoned the field almost immediately.
Critics on the whole recognize the hand of Annibale in the designs
for the whole series, but his effective execution in only two, the
present one, “The Flight into Egypt”, and that of the
“Deposition of Christ”. The other four have been variously
attributed to Albani and to followers of Annibale, such as Domenichino,
Lanfranco and Sisto Badalocchio.
|